Supreme Court Review 2013/2014 TERM
MONDAY, JULY 28, 2014
CLICK HERE TO TRACK THIS CASE

Issue:  Federal Preemption

Delia v. E.M.A.

12-98

QUESTION(S) PRESENTED

The Medicaid Act requires participating States to seek reimbursement from third-party tortfeasors for health-care expenditures they made to Medicaid recipients who are tort victims. 42 U.S.C. §§ 1396a(a)(25), 1396k(a) (2006). To enforce that requirement when the recipient and a third-party resolve their tort dispute through judgment or settlement, North Carolina law provides that the State has a subrogation right to, and may assert a lien upon, the lesser of one-third of the recipient's recovery or the State's actual medical expenditures. N.C. Gen. Stat. § 108A-57 (2011).

The question presented is whether N.C. Gen. Stat. § 108A-57 is preempted by the Medicaid Act's anti-lien provision as it was construed in Arkansas Department of Health & Human Services v. Ahlborn, 547 U.S. 268 (2006), an issue on which the North Carolina Supreme Court and the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit are in conflict.

DECISION

Decided March 20, 2013 HOLDING

The federal anti-lien provision preempts North Carolina’s irrebuttable statutory presumption that one-third of a tort recovery is attributable to medical expenses. The law here at issue, N. C. Gen. Stat. Ann. §108A–57, reflects North Carolina’s effort to comply with federal law and secure reimbursement from third-party tortfeasors for medical expenses paid on behalf of the State’s Medicaid beneficiaries. In some circumstances, however, the statute would permit the State to take a portion of a Medicaid beneficiary’s tort judgment or settlement not “designated as payments for medical care.” The Medicaid anti-lien provision, 42 U. S. C. §1396p(a)(1), bars that result.

KENNEDY, J., delivered the opinion of the Court, in which GINSBURG, BREYER, ALITO, SOTOMAYOR, and KAGAN,JJ., joined. BREYER,J., filed a concurring opinion. ROBERTS, C. J., filed a dissenting opinion, in which SCALIA and THOMAS, JJ., joined.

Text of Opinion
pdf download
html (external site)

CERTIORARI STAGE

Granted September 25, 2012

Certiorari Stage Documents
      Petition for Certiorari (pdf download)
Brief in Opposition (pdf download)
Petitioner's Reply (pdf download)

PROCEEDING BELOW

United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Decided March 22, 2012
pdf download